Home » Marguerite Whitley: O.J. Simpson’s First Wife, Children and Life After Divorce

Marguerite Whitley: O.J. Simpson’s First Wife, Children and Life After Divorce

Marguerite Whitley

Marguerite Whitley is best known as O.J. Simpson’s first wife and the mother of his three oldest children, Arnelle, Jason, and Aaren Simpson. She married Simpson in 1967. This was before his NFL fame reached its peak. Their marriage ended in 1979. After years near a very public life, she largely stepped away from attention.

Here’s what to know about Marguerite Whitley’s life with Simpson, the family they built, the loss of their daughter Aaren, her rare public comments during the 1995 trial, and the quiet life she chose afterward.

She Knew O.J. Simpson Before He Was Famous

Marguerite knew Simpson in San Francisco when they were still young. Their relationship began before college football made him a national name.

Los Angeles Times reporting on Simpson’s early life described her as a high school sweetheart. Another Times account noted that she had first dated Simpson’s close friend Al Cowlings. She and Simpson later became a couple.

That timing shaped her place in his story. She knew him before the Heisman Trophy. She knew him before the Buffalo Bills. Film roles, major ad deals, and huge fame came later.

Their 1967 Marriage Came at a Turning Point

Marguerite and Simpson married on June 24, 1967. He was 19. He had just transferred to the University of Southern California.

ESPN’s 2024 account of Simpson’s life says he moved to Los Angeles with Marguerite the day after the wedding. He needed to prepare for his first season at USC.

His football rise came fast. USC won the national title that season. Simpson won the Heisman Trophy in 1968. The Buffalo Bills made him the first pick in the 1969 NFL draft.

Marguerite Whitley was beside him as that change happened. Their young marriage had to adjust to travel and new money. Media attention also grew fast. Life with a football star was no longer simple.

Arnelle, Jason, and Aaren Built Their First Family

The couple had three children together.

See also  Who Is Alexander Bauer? Inside Melanie Griffith and Steven Bauer's Private Firstborn Son

Arnelle was born in 1968. Jason followed in 1970. Their youngest child, Aaren, was born in 1977.

The family spent much of Simpson’s Buffalo Bills career in western New York. He became a major sports star. Marguerite kept a much quieter public profile.

Later reporting on the Simpson family also confirms that Arnelle, Jason, and Aaren were the three children from his first marriage.

Arnelle and Jason later appeared in public at key moments in their father’s life. Aaren’s life ended in a family tragedy.

The Loss of Aaren Simpson

In August 1979, Aaren died after a drowning accident in the family swimming pool. She was 23 months old.

The Los Angeles Times noted the loss in its 2024 obituary of Simpson. The paper also said he rarely spoke about the accident in public.

The death came during an already painful year for the family. Marguerite and Simpson’s marriage was also ending.

For Marguerite Whitley, the loss of Aaren remains one of the saddest known parts of her family story.

Fame Changed the Shape of Their Marriage

By the 1970s, Simpson was more than a football player. He was acting in films. He appeared in national ads. He drew attention almost everywhere he went.

Marguerite preferred a quieter life. Simpson later said fame had become a major problem in the marriage. Even a simple walk could turn into a public scene.

The Los Angeles Times also reported that the marriage came under pressure as his fame grew. His work also kept him on the road for long periods.

The couple separated during his playing years. Simpson met Nicole Brown in 1977 while he was still married. Marguerite and Simpson divorced in 1979. They had been together as husband and wife for nearly 12 years.

Her 1995 Interview Gave Rare Insight

Marguerite rarely spoke in public after the divorce. That made her 1995 interview with Barbara Walters stand out.

See also  Asake Bomani: Art Career, Danny Glover, Family and Legacy

She looked back on the marriage as one that began when both of them were very young. She spoke about raising children. She also spoke about sudden money and the strain of fame.

Walters asked about claims that Simpson had been violent during the marriage. Marguerite denied that he had physically abused her.

Inside Edition’s review of the interview records her denial. It also covers her comments about the early years of the marriage.

That interview remains one of the clearest public records of Marguerite speaking in her own voice.

Marguerite Whitley During the 1995 Murder Trial

Marguerite returned to public view during O.J. Simpson’s 1995 murder trial.

She attended court with members of the family. She also said she believed her former husband was innocent of the murders of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman.

Her name came up as a possible witness. She did not testify. Her lawyer said she did not have relevant evidence to offer the court.

Her presence drew attention for a clear reason. She had known Simpson before fame. She had also shared more than a decade of family life with him.

Even then, she did not turn the trial into a public career. After that period, she again moved away from the media.

Life After the Divorce Stayed Quiet

Marguerite did not build a celebrity brand from her first marriage.

She did not become a regular TV guest. She also did not spend years giving interviews about Simpson. Her later life stayed far less public than the lives of many people around the case.

Older reporting says she married Rudolph Lewis in 1986. That marriage later ended. She then married Anthony Thomas in 1992. Thomas appeared with her during the Barbara Walters interview in 1995.

After that, Marguerite Whitley largely stayed out of major national coverage. Her public story became much quieter than the world around her former husband.

See also  Heather Helm's Real Estate Career Is More Than Matthew Lillard's Love Story

Her Children Kept the Family Story in View

Arnelle and Jason remained the two living children from Marguerite’s marriage to Simpson.

Arnelle became the more visible sibling. She spoke at her father’s 2017 parole hearing. Jason lived a lower-profile life and worked as a chef.

Their half-siblings, Sydney and Justin Simpson, are O.J. Simpson’s children with Nicole Brown Simpson.

The Simpson family has remained the subject of books and films. It has also drawn years of legal reporting and new coverage. That brings readers back to the first marriage. It is one reason Marguerite Whitley remains a common search.

Why Her Story Still Matters

Marguerite’s story covers a chapter that came before most of the events now linked to O.J. Simpson.

She knew him before the Heisman Trophy. She married him before the NFL. She raised children with him while his public image grew across sports, movies, and ads.

She also lived through the death of a young daughter. Then came the end of a long marriage. Both happened before Simpson’s later legal history changed how the public viewed him.

That makes Marguerite Whitley an important part of the early Simpson family story. She is more than a name in a list of former spouses.

For another Tozy profile about a private former spouse of a famous sports figure, read our story on Miah Harbaugh.

A Private Person in a Very Public Story

Marguerite Whitley spent years close to fame without making fame her own career.

She was Simpson’s first wife. She was the mother of Arnelle, Jason, and Aaren. She was also part of his life during the rise from college football star to national celebrity.

The marriage ended in 1979. Later events kept bringing public attention back to the family. Marguerite usually answered that attention by staying private.

That choice remains a key part of her story. The broad facts of her life are known. She kept much of her later world away from cameras and headlines.