Jeremy Yaffe was Alan Arkin’s first wife, the mother of his two oldest sons, Adam and Matthew Arkin, an original member of the children’s folk group The Baby Sitters, and later a nurse. She married Arkin in December 1955, before his big stage and film break, and their marriage ended in 1961.
In this article, we’ll look at how Jeremy Yaffe met Arkin at Bennington College, what their young family life was like before fame, how music helped pay the bills, what Alan later said about the strain at home, and how her life changed after the divorce.
Their Story Began at Bennington College
Alan Arkin was not yet a star when he met Yaffe. He was a young man who wanted to act and was still trying to find a way into the field.
After studying in California, he won a scholarship to Bennington College in Vermont, which was still mainly a women’s college and had only a small number of male theater students at the time.
That is where he met Jeremy Yaffe. In a 1998 Los Angeles Times interview, Arkin called her a Bennington classmate and said they married in 1955.
The timing tells us a lot because she knew him before the films, awards, and Broadway work that later made him famous. Their life together began while both were still young and trying to build a future.
A Young Marriage Began in December 1955
Jeremy Yaffe and Alan Arkin married in December 1955. Their first son, Adam, was born in 1956, and their second son, Matthew, followed in 1960.
The family grew fast, but steady work did not come as quickly. Arkin wanted to act, yet jobs were hard to find. A young marriage, two children, and a weak income all had to fit inside the same home.
The Independent later wrote that the couple moved to St. Louis while Arkin tried to push his acting career forward. That move came during the years when he still had no clear path to fame.
For readers who know only the actor he became, this part of the story feels very different because Arkin was not living a Hollywood life. He was a young husband and father trying to find enough work to keep going.
Music Helped During the Hard Early Years
When acting did not pay enough, music became one of Arkin’s main ways to earn money. He joined The Tarriers, the folk group tied to “The Banana Boat Song,” and spent part of the 1950s singing and recording.
Those music years mattered because they helped support the family while acting remained uncertain and placed Arkin inside the folk scene growing across the United States.
Jeremy Yaffe lived through that same period. Work could change from month to month, while travel, music, bills, and two young children all shaped family life.
This is why the early marriage deserves more than a short line in a celebrity bio. It covered the years when Arkin was still trying different ways to stay creative and make a living.
The Baby Sitters Gave Jeremy Her Own Music Credit
Yaffe also had a real place in folk music herself. She was not only the wife of a man who performed.
AllMusic lists Jeremy Arkin among the original members of The Baby Sitters, a children’s folk group formed in 1958. The early lineup also included Alan Arkin, Lee Hays, and Doris Kaplan.
The group made songs for children and families with a warm, simple sound rooted in folk music rather than polished pop.
Alan later said the family group recorded more than 100 children’s songs over time, making The Baby Sitters more than a small hobby. It became a real part of the family’s early music life.
This is also one of the clearest work credits tied to Jeremy Yaffe. Her known link to show business comes through folk music, not a long film or TV acting career.
Adam and Matthew Were Born Before the Breakthrough
Adam Arkin was born in 1956, less than a year after the marriage began. Matthew Arkin was born in 1960.
Both boys arrived before their father became a major stage or film actor. Their early home life belonged to the same years of music jobs, money worry, and constant career change.
Both sons later built careers in the arts. Adam became a well-known actor and director. His TV work brought Emmy nominations for shows such as Northern Exposure, Chicago Hope, and Frasier.
Matthew also became an actor and teacher after first training and working as a lawyer, then returning to acting. By 2017, the Los Angeles Times described him as an actor, coach, and head of South Coast Repertory’s Acting Intensive Program.
Jeremy was the mother of Adam and Matthew. Alan’s third son, Anthony, came later from his marriage to actress and writer Barbara Dana.
Alan Arkin Spoke Openly About Money Trouble
The hardest part of the marriage came near the point when Arkin’s career finally began to move. Years later, he looked back on that time with unusual honesty.
In his Los Angeles Times interview, Arkin said he was broke while his marriage was falling apart. His words place money trouble and career fear inside the same period as the strain at home.
The family had two young children, little financial safety, and no promise that acting would ever turn into a stable job. That gives the story a much more human feel than the fame that came later.
The marriage ended during this hard stretch. Arkin did not give a full public account of every private reason behind the split, so the clearest picture comes from the facts he did share.
Second City Became the Turning Point
In 1960, Paul Sills invited Arkin to join The Second City in Chicago after seeing him perform with an improv group in St. Louis.
The offer changed his career because Second City gave him a stage where his quick thinking, timing, and range could stand out. He joined the troupe in 1960 and made his Broadway debut the next year.
The career rise happened at the same time the marriage was ending. The Independent reports that Arkin spent months paying off debt and divorced Yaffe soon after Matthew was born.
Jeremy Yaffe and Alan Arkin divorced in 1961. By then, the life they had built as students, young parents, and folk musicians had come to an end.
The Divorce Came Just Before Alan Arkin’s Rise
The timing created a clear break between two stages of Arkin’s life, with the hard early years belonging mostly to his first marriage. The biggest stage and film success came after it ended.
In 1963, Arkin won a Tony Award for his Broadway debut in Enter Laughing. A few years later, The Russians Are Coming, the Russians Are Coming brought him an Academy Award nomination.
From there, his career kept growing. He became known for roles in Wait Until Dark, Catch-22, The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter, Glengarry Glen Ross, Little Miss Sunshine, and many other films.
Yaffe did not move into that new Hollywood life with him. Her own next chapter went in a very different direction.
Nursing Became Her Next Career
After the divorce, Jeremy Yaffe retrained as a nurse, and The Independent also reports that she remarried.
Nursing marked a clear shift away from the music and theater world that had filled the first marriage and gave her a work life of her own outside the fame that later surrounded Alan Arkin.
Her name still appeared through the family link, especially as Adam and Matthew became public figures. But she did not turn her old marriage into a media career.
That contrast is one of the strongest parts of Jeremy Yaffe’s story. Alan became more visible with each new role, while her own work moved farther away from the spotlight.
Adam and Matthew Carried the Family Name Forward
The two sons Yaffe shared with Arkin kept the family tied to acting, but neither simply copied his father.
Adam built a long career in television and film before becoming a respected director whose work moved between comedy, drama, acting, and directing.
Matthew took a less direct route, studying law and practicing for several years before returning to the stage. He later combined acting with teaching and coaching younger performers.
Their paths help explain why readers still search for Jeremy Yaffe. Anyone who follows the Arkin family story soon reaches the woman who was there before the fame and who raised Alan’s two oldest sons.
Barbara Dana Belonged to the Next Family Chapter
Alan Arkin married actress and writer Barbara Dana in 1964. She became part of both his family life and his creative work.
Dana also became linked to later versions of The Baby Sitters. That can make old group credits confusing when several years are placed together.
Jeremy belonged to the group’s original years. Barbara came later, after Alan’s first marriage had ended.
Alan and Barbara later had a son, Anthony. Adam and Matthew were therefore Anthony’s older half-brothers, while Yaffe remained the mother of the two older sons.
Why Jeremy Yaffe Matters in Alan Arkin’s Story
It would be easy to treat a first marriage as a short note in the life of a famous actor. In this case, that would miss the heart of the early story.
Jeremy Yaffe was part of the years when Arkin was still looking for work, raising small children, singing folk music, and wondering if acting would ever become a real career.
She also had a music credit of her own through The Baby Sitters. That gives her a place in the creative history of the family, not just in its marriage record.
Their marriage ended before Arkin’s big break, which makes her part of the story behind the public story. The actor audiences later knew was shaped during years filled with family duty, money trouble, music, travel, and doubt.
The Full Picture Goes Beyond the “First Wife” Label
Jeremy Yaffe is best understood through the full arc of her early adult life. She was Arkin’s Bennington classmate, his first wife, the mother of Adam and Matthew, an original member of The Baby Sitters, and later a nurse.
Her marriage covered the years before Alan Arkin became famous, when the family was still trying to survive on uneven work. The marriage ended in 1961, just as Second City began opening the door to the career he had been chasing.
What came next moved in two very different directions. Arkin went on to Broadway, film, television, and an Oscar-winning career. Yaffe moved into nursing and a life far less tied to celebrity.
That contrast gives the story its shape. One life became highly public, while the other became much quieter, yet both stayed linked through the hard early years they shared and the two sons who carried the Arkin name into another generation.
If you enjoy stories about the people who shared a famous actor’s life before the breakthrough, read our profile of Mary Marquardt, Harrison Ford’s first wife.